Supreme Court Debates Jurisdiction Over Superstitious Practices Amid Centre's Disagreement
Supreme Court: Can decide on superstitious practices; Centre disagrees
The Indian Express
Image: The Indian Express
The Supreme Court of India is deliberating whether it has the authority to classify certain religious practices as superstitious. The Centre argues that such determinations should be left to the legislature, citing a lack of scholarly competence in secular courts. The discussion arises from petitions related to the Sabarimala temple case.
- 01Supreme Court asserts its jurisdiction to define superstitious practices.
- 02The Centre claims that secular courts lack the expertise to make such determinations.
- 03Justice Bagchi questions the implications of classifying witchcraft as a religious practice.
- 04The court is reviewing the locus standi of petitioners in the Sabarimala case.
- 05Hearing on the matter will continue, with significant implications for future cases.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
On Wednesday, the Supreme Court of India engaged in a significant debate regarding its jurisdiction to determine if certain religious practices are superstitious. Justice Joymalya Bagchi, part of a 9-judge bench, stated that the court retains residual jurisdiction in appropriate cases, despite the Centre's contention that such matters should be legislated. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta argued that secular courts lack the scholarly competence to classify religious practices, emphasizing the pluralistic nature of Indian society. The discussion was sparked by ongoing petitions related to the Sabarimala temple, where the court questioned the legitimacy of the petitioners, noting that they are not devotees of the temple. The court's deliberations could set a precedent for how superstitious practices are treated under Indian law, with the hearing expected to continue on Thursday.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
The court's ruling could influence how religious practices are viewed legally in India, affecting various communities and their beliefs.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
Reader Poll
Should secular courts have the authority to classify religious practices as superstitious?
Connecting to poll...
More about Supreme Court of India

Supreme Court Ruling Streamlines Fraud Classification Process for Banks
Mint • Apr 9, 2026

Supreme Court Hears Centre's Objection to Adultery Ruling by Former Chief Justice DY Chandrachud
Ndtv • Apr 9, 2026

Debate Over School Admissions: Aadhaar and Family ID Requirements Under RTE Act Scrutinized
Jagran Josh • Apr 8, 2026
Read the original article
Visit the source for the complete story.




