Harvard Faculty to Vote on Proposal Limiting A Grades to Combat Grade Inflation
Harvard faculty to vote on proposal to limit number of A grades in each course
The Guardian
Image: The Guardian
Harvard University's faculty will vote next week on a proposal to limit A grades to 20% of students in each course, with an additional allowance of four As. This initiative aims to address grade inflation, which has seen A grades rise significantly over the years, but it faces criticism from students and faculty alike regarding its potential impact on academic rigor and competition.
- 01The proposal aims to cap A grades at 20% per course to combat grade inflation.
- 02An internal report found that approximately 60% of grades were As during the 2024-25 academic year.
- 03Critics, including students and the Harvard Crimson's editorial board, argue the cap could harm academic rigor.
- 04The proposal includes a new internal ranking system based on raw scores rather than GPA.
- 05Faculty opinions are mixed, with some supporting the proposal and others concerned about its implications.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
Harvard University is preparing for a faculty vote on a proposal to limit the number of A grades awarded in courses to 20% of students, with an allowance for four additional As. This initiative, aimed at curbing grade inflation, comes in response to a significant increase in A grades over the years, with a report indicating that approximately 60% of grades during the 2024-25 academic year were As, compared to just 25% in 2005-06. The proposal also seeks to introduce a new internal ranking system based on raw scores rather than the traditional grade point average (GPA). Critics, including students and the Harvard Crimson's editorial board, argue that the cap could undermine academic rigor and create unnecessary competition among students. The editorial board noted that similar policies at Princeton University were eventually discontinued, suggesting that such caps may not effectively resolve the underlying issues of grade inflation. Faculty views on the proposal are mixed, with some expressing cautious support while others worry about the potential negative impact on course enrollment and faculty autonomy. The vote is scheduled for next week, and the outcome could shape grading policies at Harvard in the coming years.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
If implemented, the A grade cap could alter grading dynamics at Harvard, affecting student stress levels and competition. It may also influence how courses are structured and how students perceive their academic performance.
Advertisement
In-Article Ad
Reader Poll
Do you support the proposed cap on A grades at Harvard?
Connecting to poll...
More about Harvard University
Read the original article
Visit the source for the complete story.




