The Pittsburgh Steelers are facing a pivotal moment as they prepare for the 2026 NFL Draft, particularly concerning the future of veteran quarterback Aaron Rodgers. With the need to build a competitive team capable of playoff success, the Steelers are considering several quarterback prospects. Ty Simpson, a standout from the University of Alabama, is regarded as the consensus No. 2 quarterback in this draft class, expected to be in high demand. Although he only started one year, his potential makes him a strong candidate for Pittsburgh's first-round pick. Another intriguing option is Drew Allar from Penn State, who possesses a powerful arm and impressive athleticism but has not consistently demonstrated franchise-level performance. If available on day two or three, he could be a valuable addition. Lastly, Cole Payton from North Dakota State presents a dual-threat option with significant physical potential, although his experience against lower competition raises questions about his readiness. If the Steelers are committed to a long-term strategy, Payton could be a worthwhile gamble.